Resources
The Promotion That Wasn’t
Unstuck Monthly | May 2026
The behaviors that got you promoted will keep you from leading.
Six Months In
A new client comes to me six months into a new senior role. He pulls up his calendar in our first session and walks me through last week: twenty-three meetings, four decks reviewed past midnight, and not a single block of time he'd call leadership work. He's working harder than he ever has, and the team still isn't moving. His boss seems vaguely disappointed but won't say why. He's starting to wonder if he was the wrong pick.
He wasn't the wrong pick. He's been promoted into a senior role and is doing what every promotion he's ever earned has rewarded him for doing: more. More hours, more decisions personally owned, more problems pulled into his own queue, more late nights spent perfecting work he could have delegated. By every measurable input, he's giving the role everything he has.
It isn't working, and he can't see why.
He's not alone. His situation is part company failure to prepare him, part his own failure to evolve. Both can be addressed.
The Numbers Behind the Pattern
According to McKinsey, 40 to 50 percent of new leaders fail within their first 18 months. Half. The reasons are familiar to anyone who’s lived through it: under-resourced transitions, unclear expectations, limited training, full accountability. Leaders get promoted on Friday and are expected to lead on Monday, with a quiet assumption that the skills will arrive on their own.
So leaders do the rational thing and reach for what worked before. If execution made them promotable, they execute harder. If availability made them indispensable, they become more available. If personal ownership of outcomes built their reputation, they own more outcomes, more personally. They scale the behaviors that got them here, because those behaviors are the only data they have about what success looks like in this organization.
Why Smart People Default to the Familiar
This is rational behavior under pressure. Behavioral economists have a name for it: status quo bias. Under uncertainty, people disproportionately default to the familiar, not because the familiar is better but because it’s known. The cost of staying the same feels smaller than the cost of changing, even when the math doesn’t support it. Add in identity, accountability without support, and the fear of being the leader who tried something new and broke something visible, and the choice to keep doing what worked becomes almost inevitable.
The trouble is that the new role rewards different behavior than the old role rewarded. Leaders who scale their old jobs don’t get promoted again. They get tired, then quietly replaced, often by someone less talented who happened to figure this out faster.
A Different Job With the Same Title
When clients describe the symptoms, I ask them a version of the same question: Were you promoted to do more of what you were already doing, or were you promoted to do something different? Most leaders never stop to ask.
My clients sit with that for a minute. If you're reading this and recognizing yourself, you might be sitting with it too.
The work of senior leadership is a different category of work than what made them promotable. It asks them to build the conditions for other people to execute, rather than executing themselves. To make fewer decisions personally and more decisions structurally. To be less available in the moment so they can be more useful over the quarter. To tolerate the discomfort of watching a director do something they could have done faster, because that's how the organization gets bigger than them.
Their organization should have prepared them for this. It didn't.
A Short Diagnostic
Three questions for any leader, at any stage of the transition.
When something needs to get done and it falls into the gap between your team and you, who picks it up?
When you look at last week’s calendar, how much of it was you doing the work of a senior leader, and how much was you doing the work of the role you used to have?
If you disappeared for two weeks, what would fall apart, and is that on your team or on you?
If you read those questions and felt defensive, that’s information. If you read them and felt nothing, that’s worse.
Closing the Gap
Many leaders who read those questions already know the answers. Getting unstuck requires figuring out what to do about it.
Your organization left you to figure this out on your own. From here, you have three options. You can take control of your own evolution and thrive in the new role. You can choose to grind it out and simply survive. Or you can keep doing what got you here and watch someone else get the next promotion, the next opportunity, the next vote of confidence, while you wonder what changed.
Closing the gap means doing things you can't yet do well. Delegating a piece of work before you fully trust the person you're handing it to. Setting direction in a meeting before you feel certain you're right. Letting a deliverable go out a little rougher than you would have made it, because the cost of your team learning is lower than the cost of you doing it all yourself.
This is where nerve comes in: the quiet kind. The willingness to take a small action you don't feel ready for, knowing it will feel risky, and doing it anyway.
One Last Thing
Here's what I've come to believe after watching this pattern play out enough times.
The leaders who make it through this transition don't work harder than the ones who don't. They work differently, because they were willing to let parts of who they were fall away.
Hold on tight to your values. Hold on tight to your sense of purpose and the mission that brought you to this work. Those are the things that should never change.
But how you go about realizing that mission — the behaviors, the tasks, the control, the daily reflex to be the one who handles it — those have to evolve. You may need to give yourself permission to let them go. Nobody else is going to give it to you.
The promotion was the easy part. The evolution is the work.
“Our work together came at a pivotal time in my career and the team and organization that I lead are better off today because of the leadership coaching I have received from Alex.” — Chandler, Vice President, Community and Technical College System
Make the evolution deliberate.
Companies often leave new leaders hanging. Having a thought partner in your corner makes the path forward clearer.
If you're in the middle of a transition like this — or seeing one coming — let's talk about what to keep, what to let go, and what to do next.
Great conversations start with shared insights. My coaching practice, like this newsletter, thrives on connections. If you know someone who's navigating their own sticking points, I’d love for you to share this with them.
